Avoid These 3 Common Mistakes in Your Organization’s Diversity & Inclusion Efforts
You know the research. You’ve done the training.
You’re bringing in a more diverse workforce.
You ask yourself, “Where are the results?”
If your experience is like many others, your organization’s commitment to diversity & inclusion just isn’t translating into desired results. You know that accessing the full potential of all your talent is a strategic imperative – studies have repeatedly shown that diverse teams drive better business performance, and companies with more diversity become more innovative, and resilient, and better able to respond to complex challenges.
But it may feel like your organization is making slow progress, and you are looking for new solutions.
Unfortunately, most diversity programs aren’t increasing diversity — at least, they’re not getting results in terms of numbers or strategic objectives.
Another recent study found nearly 75% of employees in underrepresented groups — women, racial and ethnic minorities, and LGBTQ employees — do not feel they’ve personally benefited from their companies’ diversity and inclusion programs. That doesn’t even address a broader array of traits and identities, such as generation and national culture, or people with disabilities, which are also relevant to an organizations’ workforce.
3 Common Diversity & Inclusion Missteps to Avoid
Organizations struggle with their workplace diversity and inclusion initiatives for many reasons. We see a few common missteps:
1. Awareness-building without targeted action. The value of diverse teams and organizations is widely documented. Numerous forms of diversity training have been deployed. Stories about pay inequity, overt and unintentional discrimination, and the experiences of marginalized employees and communities make headlines all over the world. And more and more people are learning about unconscious bias — the implicit associations about groups of people that we are unaware of and may not even consciously believe.
But awareness alone doesn’t result in desired change. In fact, some studies have tied diversity training to an increase in bias and to a backlash against diversity.
People across organizations are frustrated. Champions of diversity wonder what else they can do. Leaders are looking for results. Employees are tired of the messaging and training that makes people uncomfortable, rather than supports them in their real-life, day-to-day interactions. Everyone wishes there was a better solution.
What to do instead: We’ve learned from our clients — and our own experiences — that aligning awareness and education with targeted action can change the pattern and foster real progress. Progress requires thoughtful leadership, so focus your efforts on leadership training that will promote more equitable, diverse, and inclusive organizations.
2. New expectations without leadership engagement. Often, efforts to create more diverse & inclusive organizations are viewed as merely HR work or as standalone initiatives. A diversity initiative is launched, a compensation review is conducted to evaluate pay equity, or executives set expectations for greater diversity and inclusion — but the crucial role of leaders is minimized.
The capability to analyze issues through an equity lens, to authentically engage diverse people and perspectives, and to interact across cultures and one-on-one in ways that foster inclusion and belonging are critical leadership skills for an evolving world.
Managers throughout the organization need to learn and practice specific behaviors. They need to see how making changes or developing new skills will make a difference to them, their colleagues, and their organization. And they need ongoing feedback, challenge, and support to learn from experience.
What to do instead: Organizations that are serious about improving their diversity & inclusion efforts need to define a leadership strategy, update leadership development practices, and create accountability systems to ensure leaders have the understanding and capability needed to leverage the talent of all employees.
3. Individual responsibility without organizational change. People representing marginalized or minority groups have long been expected to change themselves to accommodate the dominant workplace or societal culture. Their success hinges largely on their ability — or inability — to adapt to the “norm,” whatever that is in their context. They have also had the burden of speaking for, or explaining the perspective of, their social identity group(s), or advocating for greater fairness, representation, and power.
The emphasis on individual responsibility often continues when organizations introduce well-intentioned measures to foster greater diversity & inclusion. Individuals who are part of dominant groups or who hold positions of power and influence are charged with learning and implementing changes. “Diverse” individuals are often put in the spotlight or expected to help their colleagues get it right. On any given day, an employee may be working with a willing ally, compliant colleague, or resistant co-worker.
But by leaning too heavily on individuals without developing organizational processes and practices, decisions are inconsistent, and people remain wary, or even demoralized. Progress is slow, and the positive impact of diversity in the workplace falls short of expectations.
What to do instead: To accelerate positive impact, invest in culture and systems that create and reinforce diversity & inclusion throughout the employee experience — and give equity top priority. Without a focus on equity, efforts to promote diversity and inclusion are laudable, but not sustainable.
Fast-Forward Your Diversity & Inclusion Efforts With EDI
Making progress on diversity and inclusion is top of mind for leaders around the world, with 1/3 of those we recently surveyed naming it as a top trend to address in 2020 and beyond.
At CCL, we believe the most successful DEI (diversity, equity & inclusion) efforts prioritize equity first.
To reinforce this point, our perspective is that DEI initiatives are more effective as EDI initiatives, emphasizing the importance of pursuing diversity and inclusion only after investing in a culture of equity as the foundation.
Organizations can tackle the challenges, avoid serious missteps, and fast-forward progress by using our 4-stage REAL framework to take action. The approach involves senior leaders taking responsibility for organizational change while addressing EDI through team and individual capability.
Ultimately, EDI is about culture, leadership, and making your business better. The way forward is different for each organization, but you can learn from what has not worked in the past. With a tailored approach that aligns awareness with action, addresses organizational culture and systems, and engages leaders, your company can earn the benefits of a diverse workforce and reduce the negative consequences of getting it wrong.
We can partner with you to create custom leadership solutions to shift mindsets, behaviors, and practices towards more equitable, diverse, and inclusive teams and organizations. Learn more about our EDI practice.